Consumer and Community

The George Institute calls for community-driven, intersectoral action at COP28

From 30 November – 12 December, world leaders will gather in Dubai for the 2023 United Nations Climate Change Conference, COP28. For the first time, the conference will include a designated ‘health day’ and a climate-health ministerial where governments around the world will endorse a Declaration on Climate and Health, developed with the World Health Organization (WHO) in recognition of the unprecedented threat to human health the climate crisis represents.   

The George Institute will be sending a delegation of experts and advocates to COP28 and expects to have its Observer status formally approved by the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change during the conference. The Institute will join other Observer organisations, including UN agencies and inter- and non-governmental organisations, in participating in future COPs.   

COP 28 priorities

 

COP 28 priorities

Global heating has sparked the worst health and humanitarian catastrophe in history. The George Institute is once again making an urgent call for world leaders to centre the voices of communities whose health, well-being and futures have been most impacted, ensuring they are at the heart of national climate action plans and debate.

Communities experiencing marginalisation as a legacy of historic power structures now face the twin threats of rapid environmental change and a fast-growing burden of non-communicable diseases and injuries (NCDIs), already the biggest killer of people globally. Rates of injury, cardiovascular and acute and chronic kidney diseases, respiratory illness, and mental health conditions are rising along with temperatures.[1][2]  

With a growing global population and increasing urbanisation, cities are facing huge pressures. Globally, road traffic crashes kill 1.35 million people every year and are responsible for over 50 million more non-fatal injuries.[3] Ninety per cent of these deaths and injuries occur in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). At the same time, urban traffic is a major source of pollutants, which not only contribute to global heating but have both short- and long-term adverse health effects, including serious impairment to lung function and links with chronic respiratory disease and other major NCDs, particularly for children.[4] 

The impact of climate change is supercharged by unhealthy and unsustainable environments where people live, play, learn and work. The global food system, for example, promotes the consumption of diets high in fat, sugar and salt and low in diversity, fuelling a pandemic of diabetes, cardiovascular diseases, malnutrition and other NCDs.[5][6] It is also one of the largest contributors to environmental degradation - through greenhouse gas emissions, water use and deforestation - and one of the sectors hardest hit by climate change. Access to information about the nutritional quality and environmental impacts of the food we eat is a basic consumer right, yet is lacking. 

Governments need to plan for increasing rates of NCDIs and include these population health impacts within climate risk and vulnerability assessments. At the COP, we urge delegates at the health-climate ministerial discussion to commit to developing a framework to address climate risks to health and health systems within adaptation plans. 

The George Institute for Global Health calls on governments at COP28 to make a number of commitments aligned to the research we conduct and our findings: 

Centre the voices of communities most affected by the climate crisis in setting policy agendas and allocating resources, prioritising human rights and health equity. 

  • Ensure that the Traditional Knowledge of First Nations and Tribal peoples, and the voices of other communities experiencing marginalisation, are heard. 
  • Focus on women, girls, young people and other groups who experience the impacts of the climate crisis disproportionately, including when allocating health-related climate financing. 
  • Establish mechanisms to ensure the meaningful participation and inclusion of communities and civil society in climate-related policymaking. 

Build food and agriculture systems which promote nutrition security and the consumption of healthy, sustainable diets. 

  • Work with First Nations and Tribal peoples, local communities, consumers and researchers to identify and implement policies that can improve the diversity, nutritional quality and sustainability of the food supply, while reducing food loss and waste.  
  • Increase the knowledge and evidence base on the contribution Indigenous, agroecological and small-scale farming can provide to deliver sustainable, healthy diets for all. 
  • Ensure accurate and timely information about the nutritional quality and environmental impacts of food is easily accessible to consumers.  

Build effective, equitable and sustainable primary health care systems to reduce and respond to the twin threats of the climate crisis and the growing burden of NCDIs. 

  • Strengthen the provision of mental health support and other primary health care services to improve psychological resilience and adaptation skills in the wake of environmental damage. 
  • Develop robust digital platforms to monitor and evaluate NCDIs and climate threats and generate high-quality data to support decision-making. 
  • Include health in nationally determined contributions and reduce the contribution of the health care sector to environmental degradation by researching and implementing low-emission primary health care solutions. 
  • Prioritise the development of climate risk and vulnerability assessments for high-risk communities and a framework of vulnerability indicators. 

Challenge commercial actors and rapidly transition away from harmful systems, practices and commodities to secure co-benefits for the health of people and the planet. 

  • Set and enforce urban speed limits of 30km/h or lower to address road traffic injuries, promote physical activity, and reduce air pollutants 
  • Regulate the burning of plastic waste, improve waste management systems and hold stakeholders to account for collecting and controlling the waste they create. 
  • Identify alternative water sources for coastal and inland communities vulnerable to rising drinking water salinity; such as rainwater harvesting and reverse osmosis. 
  • Call for a strengthened UNFCCC Conflict of Interest Policy that further reduces the opportunity for influence by unhealthy commodity industries on COP outcomes. 

The George Institute is proud to be a member of the WHO Civil Society Working Group to Advance Action on Climate and Health, and a signatory of the COP28 Recommendations developed by the Global Climate & Health Alliance, whom we have recently joined as a member. 

The George Institute seeks to ensure that evidence informs the development and implementation of social, economic and environmental policies to address climate change and other urgent global health challenges. We are committed to placing at the heart of our work Traditional Knowledges of First Nations and Tribal Peoples and the voices of other communities experiencing marginalisation. We work closely with these communities, stakeholders and policymakers at local, national and global levels to address and reverse the ongoing impacts of climate change on human health and equity. Read more about our planetary health work here. 

Find out more about two of our flagship planetary health initiatives: 

References

[1] Climate change may be causing chronic kidney disease by triggering dehydration and heat stress (2016) The George Institute for Global Health. Available at: https://www.georgeinstitute.org/media-releases/climate-change-may-be-causing-chronic-kidney-disease-by-triggering-dehydration-and  

[2] Why Mental Health is a priority for action on climate change. World Health Organization (2022) Available at: https://www.who.int/news/item/03-06-2022-why-mental-health-is-a-priority-for-action-on-climate-change.   

[3] Road traffic injuries (2022) World Health Organization. Available at: https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/road-traffic-injuries.   

[4] Atkinson, R.W., et al., Fine particle components and health—a systematic review and meta-analysis of epidemiological time series studies of daily mortality and hospital admissions. Journal of exposure science & environmental epidemiology, 2015. 25(2): p. 208-214.  

[5] Diverse healthy diets for all: how a focus on healthy diets can transform food systems and climate action, Climate and Planet (2023) Health Climate Network. Available at: https://healthandclimatenetwork.org/diverse-healthy-diets-for-all-how-a-focus-on-healthy-diets-can-transform-food-systems-and-climate-action/.  

[6] Centre of Research excellence: Healthy Food, healthy planet, healthy people (2022) The George Institute for Global Health. Available at: https://www.georgeinstitute.org/projects/centre-of-research-excellence-healthy-food-healthy-planet-healthy-people

 

Trans fat limits in Kenya

Submission on options for improving the composition of the food supply in relation to industrially-produced trans fats in Australia and New Zealand

The George Institute for Global Health has responded to the Public Consultation Regulation Impact Statement on options for improving the composition of the food supply in relation to industrially-produced trans fats in Australia and New Zealand. Food Ministers and the Food Regulation Standing Committee should be commended for their commitment to removing industrially-produced trans fats from the Australian and New Zealand food supplies, which will save lives and improve health equity.

  • A comprehensive, objective understanding of the trans fats content of foods in Australia and New Zealand is extremely difficult due to deficiencies in labelling
  • Where it has been possible to assess trans fats content, drawing upon voluntary declarations on products, the situation is concerning – 38% of packaged products that quantify trans fats content in Australia exceed the 2% of total fats limit specified in the WHO best practice policy
  • Some companies may be disguising known or potential industrially-produced trans fats content – in addition to products that declare trans fats content, 3660 packaged products (13% of total) in Australia may contain hidden industrially-produced trans fats, as identified through ingredients lists

The George Institute recommends that mandatory action to reduce and ultimately eliminate industrially-produced trans fats in the Australian and New Zealand food supply be taken. Mandatory trans fats policies have proven to be effective, cost-effective and equitable in many settings around the world.

A complete prohibition on the use of partially-hydrogenated oil in all settings will be easy for industry to implement and governments to monitor. A limit on trans fats content, set to the WHO-recommended level of 2% of total fats content, is a suitable backup but will be more difficult to implement and evaluate. Voluntary reformulation options will not be effective and cannot be supported.

“We welcome the sound, well-evidenced analysis and conclusions in the options paper released by the Food Regulation Standing Committee. Effective action on toxic trans fats in Australia and New Zealand should now be within reach, bringing us in line with almost every other high-income country around the world,” said Damian Maganja, Research Associate and PhD Candidate in the Food Policy Division at The George Institute. “This will protect the community from harm while supporting the export capacity and reputation of our domestic food industry. We must remain alert, however, to the possibility of denials and delays by those who wish to continue to profit from the manufacture, promotion and sale of harmful products.”